Exploring the Merits of HDHP versus PPO: Which Option Suits You Better?
To choose the right health coverage, you need to consider the pros and cons of an HDHP versus a PPO. Your optimum choice depends on various factors such as your health status, lifestyle, number of dependents, and financial situation.
Here, we'll delve into these factors to help you decide which insurance plan suits you best.
What is an HDHP?
HDHP, or high-deductible health insurance plan, is a type of insurance with a yearly deductible of $1,600 or more for an individual and $3,200 or more for a family in 2024. The minimum deductible increases to $1,650 for individuals and $3,300 for families in 2025.
These plans are known for high deductibles, which means you have to cover substantial out-of-pocket expenses before the insurance covers the rest of your bills. However, they have lower monthly premiums compared to PPOs, which are explained next.
HDHPs also have higher out-of-pocket maximums. In 2024, individual plans can have a maximum of $8,050 ($8,300 in 2025) in out-of-pocket expenses before the insurance covers 100% of your remaining bills. For families, the maximum can reach $16,100 ($16,600 in 2025).
Given the high deductibles, HDHPs may not be ideal if you often visit the doctor. But if you usually avoid medical care and aim to reduce your monthly expenses, they are a good option.
Pros
- Lower monthly premiums
- Eligibility to contribute to a health savings account
- Larger provider networks
Cons
- High deductibles (often in the thousands)
- Higher out-of-pocket maximums
What is a PPO?
PPO, or preferred provider organization plan, has lower deductibles than HDHPs, making them a suitable choice if you frequently visit doctors and do not want to pay high out-of-pocket expenses before your insurance kicks in.
PPOs come with disadvantages such as higher premiums and smaller provider networks, which could complicate matters if you travel frequently and need medical care outside your network.
Pros
- Lower deductibles
- Lower out-of-pocket maximums
Cons
- Higher premiums
- Ineligibility to contribute to a health savings account
- Smaller provider networks
Comparing Costs
The most affordable health insurance plan for you depends on how often you or your family seek medical care.
Let's examine the following example plans:
| HDHP | PPO || --- | --- || Annual Premiums | $5,000 | $7,500 || Deductible | $4,500 | $1,000 |
Regardless of the plan you choose, you need to pay your premiums to maintain coverage. However, you may not always have to meet your deductible.
If you avoid medical visits altogether, the HDHP is more cost-effective, saving you approximately $2,500 compared to the PPO plan. But if you face a $5,000 medical bill, the PPO plan would be more financially beneficial, costing you about $8,500 in premiums and deductibles, compared to $9,500 with the HDHP.
It's essential to consider nature of your health when making a decision. If you frequently visit the doctor, a PPO might be a better fit. If medical visits are rare, an HDHP would likely be more affordable.
Annual premiums
Do keep in mind that both HDHPs and PPOs also have copays or coinsurance in addition to premiums and deductibles. These are not included in the provided example. Coinsurance is a percentage of your hospital bill that you are responsible for even after meeting your deductible. The percentage can vary depending on the type of service needed.
You continue to pay coinsurance until you reach your out-of-pocket maximum for the year, at which point your health insurance covers all additional costs. Remember this when selecting the health insurance plan that fits your needs best.
HDHPs and HSAs
Individuals with HDHPs have the opportunity to contribute to an HSA, a benefit unavailable to PPO policyholders. An HSA is a specialized savings account created to hold funds intended for medical expenses. They offer various financial advantages, including:
$5,000
- Tax-free contributions
- Tax-free growth
- Tax-free withdrawals for qualified medical expenses
- Paying into an HSA decreases your taxable income for the year, much like contributing to most 401(k)s and traditional IRAs.
- Certain HSAs give you the option to invest your funds, much like with a retirement account.
- If you utilize the funds for medical expenses at any age, the withdrawals are tax-exempt.
- You can make non-medical withdrawals once you reach 65 (if you're under 65, there's a 20% penalty), but you'll have to pay taxes on the withdrawals.
- Unlike contributions to flexible spending accounts (FSAs), HSA contributions carry over from year to year.
- Some companies that provide HSAs also offer an HSA match, which is similar to a 401(k) match.
The HSA shares some similarities with a retirement account, even though it wasn't designed with that intention. It can actually serve as an effective retirement plan, allowing you to use the funds without penalty once you're older, even if you don't need them for medical expenses.
In 2024, individuals with individual HDHPs can contribute up to $4,150 to an HSA, while those with family plans can contribute up to $8,300. These limits can change annually. In 2025, these limits increase to $4,300 and $8,550, respectively. Individuals aged 55 and over can add an additional $1,000 to these limits in 2024 and 2025.
$7,500
Other considerations
Other considerations
If you're having trouble deciding between an HDHP and a PPO, consider the following questions:
- How often do you visit the doctor?
- Do you have any long-term health issues?
- Do you have any upcoming medical expenses, such as a child's birth or surgery?
- Are you considering coverage for yourself or a larger family?
- Is having a large network of healthcare providers important to you?
Your answer may change year by year. When your policy term is approaching its end, revisit this list of questions to see if anything has changed. If you believe a different type of health insurance might be more affordable, consider switching policies.
Related Investing Topics
What Is an HSA and How Does It Work?
Health savings accounts allow you to pay for medical expenses using pre-tax money.
Deductible
Saving on Healthcare in Retirement
If you're planning for Medicare, it's not free. Here are some tips for saving on healthcare costs in retirement.
Roth IRA vs. 529 Plan for Education Savings
Which investment plan is better for saving for your child's college education?
$4,500
Roth IRA vs. Traditional IRA
What's the difference, and how do each work?
Remember, it's not just about costs. Look at what each plan covers, ensuring the medications and treatments you or your family need are included. Comparing multiple policies side by side can help you find the best value. It may require some time, but it's the best way to find the best coverage for you.
Our site has a disclosure policy.
$1,000
In the context of retirement planning, an HDHP paired with an HSA can serve as an effective retirement savings plan due to its tax benefits and investment opportunities.
Given the financial situation during retirement, having the ability to tap into the HSA funds for medical expenses or other purposes without penalty can be a significant advantage.
