Policy Decision on Personalized Advertising in Europe Should Favor Freedom Over Regulation
In the digital landscape of Europe, a contentious discussion is brewing around the potential ban of personalized online advertising. Margrethe Vestager, the European Executive Vice-President in charge of digital policies and competition, has expressed concerns that such a ban could negatively impact businesses.
The crux of the matter lies in the fact that most targeted online advertising does not reveal personal data to advertisers. Instead, advertising platforms show ads to people who meet certain criteria, ensuring a more efficient and cost-effective advertising experience for businesses.
For businesses, a ban on personalized advertising could lead to significant revenue losses. Personalized ads typically yield higher conversion rates and Return on Investment (ROI) compared to generic ads. Without targeting, advertising becomes less efficient and more costly for advertisers. Platforms and ad tech companies may also face increased operational complexity or may even withdraw certain ad services, as seen with Meta’s planned ban on political ads in the EU citing "unworkable" rules.
Smaller businesses or startups could struggle more to reach their niche audiences, leading to less effective marketing spend and reduced competitiveness. The lack of personalization could also make ads more intrusive and less relevant, resulting in a poorer user experience.
For consumers, the loss of personalized ads could increase exposure to unwanted or irrelevant ads, reducing the utility of online services funded by advertising revenues. However, consumer privacy protections and reduced risk of manipulation through microtargeted political advertising could be viewed as benefits in this context.
The restrictions on personalized advertising could discourage investment in data-driven digital marketing technologies and AI systems designed to improve ad targeting and user engagement. Platforms and advertisers might be less motivated to develop novel advertising formats or technologies if the regulatory environment limits data use. The broader digital ecosystem could see slowed progress in personalized content delivery, impacting areas beyond advertising such as e-commerce and personalized recommendations.
Critics of personalized advertising advocate for more use of contextual advertising. Contextual advertising shows ads based on webpage content or user search keywords, providing a less intrusive alternative to personalized advertising. The Digital Services Act (DSA) package proposes additional transparency rules for online advertising, which could potentially address concerns about user privacy and data protection without adversely affecting businesses or consumers.
The goal should be to make consumers better off without making businesses worse off through improved transparency rules. A ban on personalized online advertising could negatively impact businesses, consumers, and innovation. A restaurant wishing to reach users of a particular age and in a specific area might struggle without personalized advertising, as there is no efficient way to identify such users with contextual advertising. In many cases, contextual advertising is not very useful for businesses, especially those with specific targeting requirements.
Some European policymakers advocate for a ban on personalized online advertising as part of the DSA. However, it is crucial to consider the potential negative impacts, such as reduced revenue for free online apps and services, potential charges or discontinuation of services, and slowed innovation in ad technologies.
In conclusion, while privacy and transparency are essential considerations, the trade-offs must be weighed carefully. European policymakers should focus on improving transparency rules for online advertising, rather than banning personalized advertising outright.
Image Credit: Picpedia
[1] European Commission. (2021). Impact Assessment: Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on a Digital Services Act and on a Digital Markets Act. Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/impact-assessment-proposal-regulation-european-parliament-and-council-digital-services-act-and-digital-markets-act_en
[2] European Data Protection Board. (2019). Guidelines 05/2019 on the concepts of controller and processor in the context of the Internet of Things and 5G (v.2.0). Retrieved from https://edpb.europa.eu/our-work-docs/our-documents/guidelines/guidelines-05-2019-concepts-controller-and-processor-context-internet-things-and-5g_en
[3] European Parliament. (2019). Report on the protection of personal data in electronic communications (2017/2076(INL)). Retrieved from https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-9-2019-0059_EN.html
[4] Vestager, M. (2019, June 13). Speech at the European Parliament's Committee on the Internal Market and Consumer Protection. Retrieved from https://ec.europa.eu/commission/commissioners/2019-2024/vestager/announcements/speech-european-parliament-s-committee-internal-market-and-consumer-protection_en
- The European Commission is debating the implication of a potential ban on personalized online advertising, as expressed in their Impact Assessment on the Digital Services Act and Digital Markets Act.
- Critics of personalized advertising advocate for an increase in the use of contextual advertising, which shows ads based on webpage content or user search keywords.
- For businesses, a ban on personalized ads could lead to significant revenue losses and reduced competitiveness, particularly for smaller businesses or startups trying to reach specific niche audiences.
- The potential downsides of a ban on personalized online advertising extend to consumers as well, who could face increased exposure to unwanted or irrelevant ads without the benefits of privacy protections and reduced risk of manipulation through microtargeted political advertising.
- European policymakers should focus on improving transparency rules for online advertising rather than a ban, avoiding potential negative impacts such as reduced revenue for free online apps and services, potential charges or discontinuation of services, and slowed innovation in ad technologies.
