Unmasking Overtrust: Identifying Unseen Dangers Through Four Key Signals
Revamped Tale:
Are you often tripped up by deceitful schemes? Beware! Over 70 million Americans have fallen victim to scams in the past five years, even the smart ones. Deception, whether it's from strangers or acquaintances, can be a lucrative business.
But it's not just outsiders that can deceive us. We can be blind to our coworkers' deceptive actions, too. A study by Washington University revealed that when team members trust each other, monitoring tends to decrease, leading to decreased awareness of each other's activities, negatively impacting performance.
As a behavioral scientist and advisor, I've found that understanding the psychology behind trust can help us avoid the pitfalls of gullibility and empower us to make smarter choices.
The Puzzle of Misjudgment
In a meta-analysis of 206 legal cases with 24,483 judges, it was discovered that people spot deception only approximately 60% of the time. Poor lie detectors are easy prey for deception and misinformation.
There are several reasons why we fall for falsehoods:
• Automatic Belief
We tend to accept things at face value and believes what we hear, especially when we aspire for promotions or board appointments.
• Time Constraints
Busy people resist reflection, and it's easy to get fooled because we don't have time for thorough due diligence on every presentation, project, or pitch. A 2022 Kings College London report found that 47% of respondents claim that "deep thinking" has become a rarity.
• Selective Biases
Our thinking patterns follow predictable patterns, thanks to what I call selective biases, or "deaf spots"—the cousins of blind spots. Authority bias, relationship bias, and the halo effect are a few examples that increase the risk of overtrust.
• Authority Bias
When we rely too much on experts in positions of power without critical thinking, we risk falling prey to manipulation and deceit. The legendary Silicon Valley firm Theranos promised revolutionary blood-testing technology, and its CEO, Elizabeth Holmes, duped investors and employees with her charismatic leadership style.
• Relationship Bias
Trust in relationships can blind us to warning signs. Auditors for the German firm Wirecard, for example, missed out on a €1.9 billion fraud for a decade, leading to one of Europe's biggest financial scandals.
• The Halo Effect
The halo effect refers to assuming that someone is capable in other areas because they excel in one. Adam Neumann, former CEO of WeWork, charmed investors and employees with his vision, despite questionable business practices.
Understanding these deaf spots can help us avoid the traps of gullibility and victimhood.
A Dose of Skepticism: Identifying Hidden Risks
While trust can foster collaboration and innovation, it can also lead to catastrophic failures like fraud, misconduct, and damaged shareholder value. To avoid such pitfalls, consider the following strategies:
1. Foster constructive skepticism
Encourage questioning, even of authority figures. Promote an environment where employees feel comfortable challenging leadership and assumptions to reduce blind trust.
2. Introduce stringent checks
Trust should be earned through accountability rather than assumed because of position. Regular audits, whistleblower protections, and oversight teams can prevent trust from turning into blind faith.
3. Reinforce psychological safety
Employees should feel comfortable voicing concerns about workplace issues without fear of being punished or degraded. High-performing teams thrive on psychological safety.
4. Recognize inherent biases
Biases can distort our trust judgments. Identify vulnerable situations where team members might trust too easily, such as during crises or under pressure.
Forging a New Path: Balancing Trust and Critical Thinking
In today's world, trust isn't the villain; it's naivete. To negotiate this fine line, follow a "distrust but verify" approach rather than blindly trusting. Ronald Reagan once said, "trust but verify." However, a smarter approach for today's leaders would be "distrust but verify."
Welcome to the Forbes Business Council, the premier networking and growth organization for business owners and leaders. Are you among them?
- Despite her charismatic leadership style, even individuals like Nuala Walsh might struggle with discerning deception, given that people only spot lies approximately 60% of the time.
- In the area of business, instances of fraud and deceit have led to significant crashes, such as the €1.9 billion fraud at Wirecard that went unnoticed by auditors for a decade.
- As an advisor, understanding the psychology behind trust can empower one to make smarter choices, much like understanding selective biases helps in identifying hidden risks and balancing critical thinking with trust, as demonstrated by the stratagems of fostering constructive skepticism and recognizing inherent biases.
